POPStudying

Pearson Edexcel 4MA1 IGCSE  ·  Topic G3.12

G3.12 Best Buy Problems

Image  ·  914 × 270

01 — Explanation

How do I compare two deals fairly?

Standardize both deals to the same quantity, then compare. Two methods work:

  • Unitary method: find the cost of one unit (Cost÷Quantity\text{Cost}\div\text{Quantity}), and compare the unit costs.
  • Common multiple method: find the cost of a convenient shared quantity (e.g. per 100 g) for each deal instead — often avoids messy decimals.

Example: 3 caps for £22.50 vs. 5 caps for £36.00.

£22.50÷3=£7.50/cap£36.00÷5=£7.20/cap£22.50 \div 3 = £7.50/\text{cap} \qquad £36.00 \div 5 = £7.20/\text{cap}

£7.20 < £7.50, so the second deal is better value.

02 — Explanation

What if the two deals use different units, like grams and kilograms?

Convert everything to the same unit first — comparing across units directly is meaningless.

Example: Brand A: 400 g for £2.56. Brand C: 1.2 kg for £7.38. Convert 1.2 kg to 12001200 g. Compare cost per 100 g: Brand A =£2.56÷4=£0.64= £2.56\div4=£0.64; Brand C =£7.38÷12=£0.615=£7.38\div12=£0.615. Brand C is cheaper.

Exam Tip: When two unit rates are very close, keep 3–4 decimal places before rounding — rounding too early (e.g. both to £0.64 vs £0.62) can make genuinely different deals look identical and cost you the comparison mark.

03 — Explanation

How do I handle "extra free" or percentage-off deals?

  • Percentage off the price: reduces the cost (numerator) — calculate the discount and subtract it before dividing.
  • Percentage extra free: increases the quantity (denominator) — calculate the bonus amount and add it to the original quantity, but use the original price.

Example: A 120 g bar with "50% extra free" gives a bonus of 6060 g, so you get 180180 g for the original price — a cheaper rate per gram, not per bar.

Common Misconception: Treating "20% off the price" and "20% extra free" as equivalent deals. One changes the cost, the other changes the quantity — they affect the unit rate differently and must be modelled separately.

04 — Explanation

How do multi-buy offers like "3 for 2" affect the unit cost?

You pay for fewer items than you receive. Divide the cost of the items you pay for by the total number you actually get.

Example: "3 for 2" at £1.80 each: you pay for 2 items (£3.60£3.60) but receive 3, so the effective cost per item is £3.60÷3=£1.20£3.60\div3=£1.20, not £1.80.

05 — Explanation

What if I'm told I need a minimum quantity?

Then the goal shifts from "cheapest per unit" to "cheapest total cost that meets the requirement" — you may have to round the number of packs up, since you can't buy a fraction of a pack.

Example: Need at least 30 batteries. Shop A: packs of 4 at £1.60. Shop B: packs of 6 at £2.70.

Shop A: ⌈30÷4⌉=8 packs→8×£1.60=£12.80Shop B: 30÷6=5 packs→5×£2.70=£13.50\text{Shop A: } \lceil 30\div4\rceil = 8 \text{ packs} \to 8\times£1.60=£12.80 \qquad \text{Shop B: } 30\div6=5 \text{ packs}\to 5\times£2.70=£13.50

Even though Shop A's unit rate (£0.40) is worse than Shop B's isn't the point here — Shop A gives the lower total cost (£12.80), so it's the best buy for this requirement.

06 — Worked example

Worked Example

A shop sells juice in two sizes: 750 ml for £1.35, or a multi-buy "two 500 ml bottles for £1.80." Which is better value per ml?

  1. 750 ml bottle: £1.35÷750=£0.0018£1.35 \div 750 = £0.0018/ml.
  2. Multi-buy: total 10001000 ml for £1.80: £1.80÷1000=£0.0018£1.80\div1000=£0.0018/ml.
  3. Both rates are identical (£0.0018/ml, or 0.18p/ml) — there is no best buy; the two options are the same value.